Cheap Rates on Hotels, Airfare & Car Rentals...
Need Assistance?
Contact Us
  • Sign In for Member Deals!
x
Reset password

Please enter the email address you signed up with and we'll immediately email you a link to reset your password.

Remember your password?

Search Hotels in the 11965 Zip Code Shelter Island Heights

2 Adults

How many guests?

Close

Have a look at the following listings consisting of 6 Hotels that we recommended in/near the 11965 Shelter Island Heights Zip Code or use the search form to perform a search for 11965 hotel availability, live rates and a wide variety of hotel filtering options. For those you who would prefer to view our 11965 hotels on a map, feel free to click the map conveniently listed below to toggle into map view. The Map contains markers for 6 hotels that we recommend in the 11965 Zip Code.

6 Hotels We Recommend in The 11965 Zip Code Shelter Island Heights, New York, United States

Select a data range for live Rates & Availability
3 of 5 Stars

81 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964, USA

Property Type Hotel
Property Highlights Beachfront Private Beach Outdoor Pool Restaurant Watersports
Select Date Range for Rates & Availability
Check Rates & Availability
Check-In: Select a date range
Check-Out:Select a date range
Upvote
Downvote
Approximately 1.41 Miles away from 11965 center
4 of 5 Stars

35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY 11965, USA

Sunset Beach is a relaxing hideaway on secluded Shelter Island. The exquisite 20 room seasonal hotel has a charming restaurant and bar where you can take in the stunning sunset views across the picturesque Peconic Bay. Inspired by the Italian and French Rivieras - Sunset Beach is one of the most unique and beloved Long Island retreats.

Select Date Range for Rates & Availability
Check Rates & Availability
Check-In: Select a date range
Check-Out:Select a date range
Upvote
Downvote
Approximately 0.87 Miles away from 11965 center

765 RT 114, Sag Harbor, NY 11963, USA

Forever Bungalows is a simple environment that encourages a true escape Our hotel rooms have a quiet boutique feel while our detached bungalows offer a more casual country vibe Great WIFi killer AC Cable All of the rooms have larger than mini fridges and the bungalows have small kitchens for light cooking A straight 15 miles from the very...

Select Date Range for Rates & Availability
Check Rates & Availability
Check-In: Select a date range
Check-Out:Select a date range
Upvote
Downvote
Approximately 7.89 Miles away from 11965 center

209 Front Street, Greenport, NY 11944, USA

Property Type Hotel
Property Highlights Outdoor Pool Fitness Center Concierge Service
Select Date Range for Rates & Availability
Check Rates & Availability
Check-In: Select a date range
Check-Out:Select a date range
Upvote
Downvote
Approximately 1.26 Miles away from 11965 center

11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965, USA

Property Location With a stay at Shelter Island House in Shelter Island Heights, you'll be next to a golf course and minutes from Shelter Island Country Club and Crescent Beach. This hotel is within close proximity of PdJ Boards Stand Up Paddle Boarding and Shelter Island Tennis Club. Rooms Make yourself at home in one of the 11 air-conditioned...

Select Date Range for Rates & Availability
Check Rates & Availability
Check-In: Select a date range
Check-Out:Select a date range
Upvote
Downvote
Approximately 0.79 Miles away from 11965 center
4 of 5 Stars

31 W. Water Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963, USA

Just a short walk from Main Street in the historic village of Sag Harbor Barons Cove will be a perfect base for exploring the Hamptons the Peconic Bay and all of the beaches dining shopping and culture that Eastern Long Island offers. Currently undergoing an extensive renovation the finished resort will offer vacationers an ideal location...

Select Date Range for Rates & Availability
Check Rates & Availability
Check-In: Select a date range
Check-Out:Select a date range
Upvote
Downvote
Approximately 6.46 Miles away from 11965 center
Best Shelter Island Heights Hotels - Map View
View Hotels on Map

6 hotels we recommend in/near the 11965 Zip Code Shelter Island Heights - Map View

x
The Pridwin Hotel
The Pridwin Hotel
$297
Sunset Beach
Sunset Beach
Select date range for rate
Forever Bungalows
Forever Bungalows
Select date range for rate
The Harborfront Inn
The Harborfront Inn
$401
Shelter Island House
Shelter Island House
$115
Barons Cove
Barons Cove
$219
x
Submit your feedback

Thank you! please answer the following question.

In order to help us service you better in the future, please take your time to rate the property.

Click Star
Click Star
Click Star
Click Star

x
Thank You!

We have received your feedback. Your feedback helps us provide you and the rest of our users with exceptional recommendations.

loading-spinnerLoading - Please Wait.
x Verification link sent