Cheap Rates on Hotels, Airfare & Car Rentals...
Need Assistance?
Contact Us
  • Sign In for Member Deals!
x
Reset password

Please enter the email address you signed up with and we'll immediately email you a link to reset your password.

Remember your password?

Search Shelter Island Hotels With a Restaurant

2 Adults

How many guests?

Close

Our Top 2 Shelter Island, New York, United States Hotels With a Restaurant

Select a data range for live pricing & availability
3 of 5 Stars

81 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964, USA

Property Type Hotel
Property Highlights Beachfront Private Beach Outdoor Pool Restaurant Watersports
From Estimate (USD)$297

Select a date range for live pricing.

Check Rates & Availability
Check-In: Select a date range
Check-Out:Select a date range
Upvote
Downvote
1.91 Miles away from Shelter Island center
4 of 5 Stars

35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY 11965, USA

Sunset Beach is a relaxing hideaway on secluded Shelter Island. The exquisite 20 room seasonal hotel has a charming restaurant and bar where you can take in the stunning sunset views across the picturesque Peconic Bay. Inspired by the Italian and French Rivieras - Sunset Beach is one of the most unique and beloved Long Island retreats.

Select Date Range for Pricing & availability
Check Rates & Availability
Check-In: Select a date range
Check-Out:Select a date range
Upvote
Downvote
1.45 Miles away from Shelter Island center

Top 2 hotels with a restaurant in/near Shelter Island - Map View

x
The Pridwin Hotel
The Pridwin Hotel
$297
Sunset Beach
Sunset Beach
Select date range for rate
x
Submit your feedback

Thank you! please answer the following question.

In order to help us service you better in the future, please take your time to rate the property.

Click Star
Click Star
Click Star
Click Star

x
Thank You!

We have received your feedback. Your feedback helps us provide you and the rest of our users with exceptional recommendations.

loading-spinnerLoading - Please Wait.
x Verification link sent